PRLL ALL-STAR TOURNAMENT TITLES IN THE 21st CENTURY
| Year | District 18 | Section* | N.Y. State | Other | KBT |
| | | | | | *Kayser-Brady |
| 2000 | Junior Girls Major Girls | | | | |
| 2001 | Junior Girls Girls’ 10’s | Girls’ 10’s | Girls’ 10’s | | |
| 2002 | Junior Girls | | | Softball T of C- MG Astros | |
| 2003 | Junior Girls Major Girls | | | | |
| 2004 | Junior Girls Girls’ 11’s | Junior Girls Girls’ 11’s | | WN – Boys’ 9’s | Girls’ 9’s |
| 2005 | Junior Girls Girls’ 11’s Girls’ 10’s | Junior Girls Girls’ 11’s | Junior Girls Girls’ 11’s | WN – Boys’ 9’s | Boys’ 9’s |
| 2006 | Senior Girls Major Girls Girl’s 11’s | Senior Girls Major Girls Girl’s 11’s | | WN – Boys’ 11’s | |
| 2007 | Major Girls | | | | Girls’ 9’s |
| 2008 | Boys’ Big- League (16-18) Girls’ 10’s | Girls’ 10’s | | WN – Boys’ 9’s Minors T of C – AAA Cardinals | |
| 2009 | Major Girls Boys’ 10’s Girls’ 11’s | Major Girls Boys’ 10’s Girls’ 11’s | Major Girls | WN – Boys’ 9’s | Boys’ 9’s Girls’ 9’s |
*Section: Rockland County (District 18) was in N.Y. Section 2 through 2008 and was moved to Section 4 in 2009
| Year | District 18 | NY Section 4* | N.Y. State | Other | KBT |
| | | *Sec 3N after 2014 | | | |
| 2010 | Boys’ 11’s | Boys’ 11’s | | T of C – MB Dodgers WN – Boys’ 9’s Softball T of C – MG Riptide | Boys’ 9’s |
| 2011 | Junior Girls Major Boys Boys’ 10’s | Junior Girls Major Boys Boys’ 10’s | Junior Girls | | |
| 2012 | Major Girls | | | | |
| 2013 | Major Boys Girls’ 10’s | Major Boys Girls’ 10’s | | | |
| 2014 | Girls’ 11’s | Girls’ 11’s | | Minors softball T of C - PRLL Inferno | |
| 2015 | Major Girls | | | ARC Tournament - Major Boys | |
| 2016 | | | | Minors T of C – PRLL Tigers | Boys’ 9’s Girls’ 9’s |
| 2017 | Girls’ 10’s | | | | |
| 2018 | Girls’ 11’s | Girls’ 11’s | Girls’ 11’s | | |
| 2019 | | | | ARC Tournament - Major Boys WN – Boys’ 11’s Jaxel Tourn. – Major Girls | END OF KBT TOURN. |
2021
| | | | WN - Boys' 9's
| |
| 2022 | | | | ARC Tournament- Major Boys;
Crotty Memorial Tournament (Suffern) - Girls' 10's | |
| 2023 | Major Boys
Girls' 11's
| Girls' 11's | | | |
| 2024 | Major Girls | | | WN - Boys' 9's
WN - Boys' 11's | |
| | | | | | |
KBT = Kayser-Brady Tournament T of C = Tournament of Champions WN = West Nyack Tournament